Smell Of Marijuana Alone Does Not Justify Vehicle Search, Minnesota Supreme Court Rules

September 14, 2023 · marijuanamoment.net

The Minnesota Supreme Court has ruled that the odor of marijuana, on its own, does not establish probable cause for police officers to search a car.

The ruling came in the case of a 2021 traffic stop in Meeker County where Adam Torgerson was pulled over by Litchfield police for having too many auxiliary lights on his vehicle’s grill. The officer claimed he smelled marijuana coming out of the open vehicle window. Torgerson, who was driving with his wife and a child, denied there was weed in the car.

A second officer approached and said he, too, smelled weed. The officers ordered everyone out of the vehicle and searched it, finding a small amount of methamphetamine and some paraphernalia.

Torgerson was not driving erratically, nor was there any evidence of a crime in open view when the officers approached the car. They based their probable cause finding solely on the marijuana odor.

A district court subsequently ruled that the evidence obtained from the search was inadmissible. Even in 2021, there were certain circumstances in which possession of marijuana was legal. Medical marijuana patients could possess it, for instance, and industrial hemp (which looks and smells a lot like regular marijuana) was also legal. The possession of small quantities of pot had also been decriminalized by that point—still prohibited by statute, but not in itself a crime.

The state of Minnesota appealed this decision to the appeals court and lost, and subsequently brought it before the Supreme Court, which today affirmed the lower courts’ decisions.

Writing for the majority, Justice Anne McKeig noted that the court previously ruled that the smell of alcohol, alone, wasn’t sufficient cause for a vehicle search. And because marijuana was also legal in some circumstances in 2021, “odor of marijuana should be considered along with the totality of any other circumstances to determine whether there is a fair probability that a search will yield contraband or other evidence,” McKeig wrote.

Outgoing Chief Justice Laurie Gildea dissented from the majority, writing that “because marijuana is contraband in Minnesota, the smell of marijuana coming from inside a car would lead a reasonable and prudent person…to conclude that there likely will be marijuana in the car.”

The ruling brings Minnesota law in line with Colorado’s, where since 2016 marijuana odor alone has not been enough to establish probable cause for a vehicle search.

Notably, however, the Minnesota ruling does not make any reference to changing circumstances following the statewide legalization of low-dose THC edibles in 2022 and personal use marijuana this year.

Regardless, the ruling is a victory for civil libertarians and racial justice advocates, who have long argued marijuana odor has been frequently used to conduct unconstitutional searches in violation of the Fourth Amendment. (Full Story)

In category:Legal
Tags:
Next Post

Justice Department Begins Issuing Marijuana Pardon Certificates Under Biden Order

The Department of Justice (DOJ) has begun issuing formal certificates to individuals whose convictions for marijuana possession were covered under President Joe Biden’s (D) mass cannabis pardon last October. The documents are intended to allow people to demonstrate that they were granted…
Read
Previous Post

Delta-8 THC, HHC, THCP are Legal, Now Illegal, Now Legal, Again - Arkansas Judge Opens Flood Gates for Hemp Derived THC Products

A recent ruling by a federal judge has raised questions within the industry: Has this judge effectively legalized hemp-derived cannabinoids such as HHC, Delta-8 THC, THCa, and THCP flower? In summary, the judge in Arkansas determined that the 2018 Farm Bill holds greater legal authority than a…
Read
Random Post

Your Take: Black Americans Have a Place in the Psychedelics Industry

Most North American Blacks say they have little-to-no participation with psychedelics. When I think about Blacks in North America and psychedelics, I have the tendency to consider the past with regards to the awareness, the availability, and the knowledge of…
Read
Random Post

Judge Nixes Montana's Cumulative Cannabis Dispensary Fees

A Montana judge struck down a state law imposing higher fees on cannabis dispensaries, ruling in favor of a group of dispensary owners who argued that the increased costs threatened their businesses. Lewis and Clark County District Court Judge Mike…
Read
Random Post

Why Do Most Americans Now Believe Smoking Cannabis is Safer Than Smoking Tobacco?

The link between lung cancer and tobacco cigarette smoking was discovered as early as 1953. It was no one else than the people who profited from the tobacco industry who were fully aware of its harms, but they were discreet about it. Through the…
Read
Random Post

Hospitality Trends Come to Retail

As the cannabis industry matures, regulatory restrictions are becoming less stringent, paving the way for dispensaries to operate more like traditional retailers and cannabis to become a normal part of everyday activities. This situation opens the door for dispensaries to co-brand with complementary…
Read