Federal Judge Allows Lawsuit About Religious Use of Hallucinogenic Tea to Move Forward

May 9, 2023 · Green Market Report

Parties exchanged legal barbs over religious freedom and the Controlled Substances Act.

A U.S. federal judge ruled that a lawsuit by an Arizona religious group seeking legal approval to use a hallucinogenic tea in its rituals can proceed.

The Arizona Yage Assembly claims the federal government seized four shipments of ayahuasca tea, which contains dimethyltryptamine (DMT), from Peru. DMT is classified as a Schedule I controlled substance under U.S. law, making it generally illegal to manufacture, distribute, or possess.

According to Law360, the group, which was founded in 2020, asserts that its religious use of ayahuasca should not be seen as a violation of the Controlled Substances Act.

However, the federal government moved for dismissal, arguing that AYA failed to state a claim under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act. This law prohibits the government from substantially burdening a person’s exercise of religion, even if the burden results from a universally applied rule.

U.S. District Judge Roslyn O. Silver ruled AYA’s claim – that it either has to abandon its religious principles or risk criminal prosecution – was sufficient to proceed under the RFRA.

Silver also dismissed the government’s challenge to AYA’s legal standing to sue. The government argued the group had not shown a specific threat of prosecution or past federal prosecutions for violations of the Controlled Substances Act related to ayahuasca use.

Silver rejected this claim, citing AYA’s reports of four separate seizures of ayahuasca shipments by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security and a warning letter from Assistant U.S. Attorney Kevin Hancock. In his letter, Hancock stated any future imports of Schedule I controlled substances like ayahuasca would be seized and forfeited unless a permit for lawful importation had been issued.

According to Silver, these allegations sufficiently show that the Controlled Substances Act has been and will continue to be enforced against the group.

Silver also denied the government’s request for a stay to allow AYA to seek an exemption from the Act, a move the Ninth Circuit has previously rejected in regards to the RFRA. (Full Story)

In categories:Legal Mushrooms Psychedelics
Next Post

Creso Pharma Acquires Australian Psychedelic Medicine Company

Creso Pharma has signed a deal to acquire 100% of Australia-based Health House International (HHI), which is focused on international distribution of medical cannabis products and possesses a number of licenses to store, distribute, import, and export controlled substances, including…
Previous Post

Scammers Using Boston Address for Cannabis Pickup Scheme

A Boston family’s address has been used as part of a cannabis delivery scam for which perpetrators created a fake business, known as Starlight Greens Delivery Dispensary, and collected money from would-be customers but delivered no product, WCVB reports. Denise King, the Boston homeowner,…
Random Post

Can psychedelics really treat OCD, depression, and chronic pain? A researcher explains how they work and their potential risks

New research is exploring whether psychedelic drugs, taken under strict medical supervision, might help in treating post-traumatic stress disorder, chronic pain, depression and obsessive-compulsive disorder. SciLine interviewed Dr. Jennifer Mitchell—a professor in the Departments of Neurology and Psychiatry & Behavioral Science…
Random Post

No New Cannabis Business Licenses in San Francisco Until 2028

Estimates say the illicit market accounts for roughly 60% of San Francisco cannabis business. San Francisco has apparently settled on a deal for a temporary ban on new marijuana business permits in the city, after an initial proposal to indefinitely prohibit new…
Random Post

Activists, Advocates, and Opportunists at the Gate

The tone in the North American cannabis industry over the past several months has been one of harsh realities and unprecedented struggles for everyone from small local growers to large multistate operators. Meanwhile, hope for federal legalization seems to lessen…
Random Post

New Jersey Revokes Cannabis Company's Licenses Over $700k in Unpaid Fees

Regulators revoked the manufacturing and cultivation permits, but allowed Harmony to keep its retail license. A vertically integrated New Jersey cannabis company had several of its business licenses yanked this week by regulators, who said the revocations were due to…